Which statement about instrument tying is NOT true?

Which statement about instrument tying is NOT true?

• A. You have as much tactile sensation/feedback as two-handed tying
• B. One-handed tying can be more convenient in certain situations
• C. Instrument tying can enhance surgical efficiency
• D. Two-handed tying always provides maximum control

Answer: (A)

The choice stating that you have as much tactile sensation/feedback as two-handed tying is not true because instrument tying typically lacks the direct tactile feedback experienced during two-handed tying. In two-handed tying, surgeons use their fingers directly on the suture and knot, allowing for more precise control and feedback on the tension and position of the knot. This direct tactile interaction is crucial in delicate procedures where the surgeon must be acutely aware of the knot's security and tissue handling. In contrast, instrument tying relies on tools to manipulate the suture, which can diminish the sense of touch and may lead to less refinement in knot placement and tension. Consequently, while instrument tying has its advantages in terms of efficiency and utility in specific scenarios, the tactile feedback inherent in two-handed tying is generally superior, making choice A the one that is not true.

The choice stating that you have as much tactile sensation/feedback as two-handed tying is not true because instrument tying typically lacks the direct tactile feedback experienced during two-handed tying. In two-handed tying, surgeons use their fingers directly on the suture and knot, allowing for more precise control and feedback on the tension and position of the knot. This direct tactile interaction is crucial in delicate procedures where the surgeon must be acutely aware of the knot's security and tissue handling.

In contrast, instrument tying relies on tools to manipulate the suture, which can diminish the sense of touch and may lead to less refinement in knot placement and tension. Consequently, while instrument tying has its advantages in terms of efficiency and utility in specific scenarios, the tactile feedback inherent in two-handed tying is generally superior, making choice A the one that is not true.